Is Buying a Rowing Machine Worth It, or Should I Just Get a Gym Membership?

If you’re considering stepping up your fitness game, you might wonder if buying a rowing machine is the right choice or if a gym membership offers more bang for your buck.

Buying a rowing machine is a great option if you’re passionate about a full-body workout and have specific fitness goals. However, rowing machines are expensive, can take up a lot of space, and are prone to breakdowns. Additionally, they cater to a specific type of exercise and may offer less variety than you’d hoped.

While they provide an excellent workout, investing in fitness equipment might be better for some people. On the other hand, a gym membership gives you access to a rowing machine and other equipment like treadmills, stationary bikes, free weights, and more, which can help diversify your workouts and target different fitness goals.

In this article, we’ll break down how rowing machines compare to gym memberships, help you decide whether investing in a rowing machine is worth it, and explain why a gym membership might be the smarter option. Keep reading to find out which path suits your fitness journey best!

Indoor Rowing Machine Vs. Gym Membership: Comparison

Cost

Rowing Machine: A standard rowing machine can range from $1,500 for a basic model to over $4,000 for higher-end options. If you want a rower with advanced features like digital performance tracking, integrated workout programs, and adjustable resistance, you’re looking at spending closer to the high end of that range.

The initial investment is significant, especially considering long-term maintenance costs. While it’s a one-time purchase, it’s still a hefty expense upfront compared to a monthly gym membership fee.

Gym Memberships: On the other hand, a gym membership typically costs between $10 and $60 per month, with some gyms offering premium services for higher prices. While paying a recurring fee, a gym membership gives you access to more than just a rowing machine.

You can use various other cardio machines, free weights, strength equipment, and fitness classes. Plus, you won’t have to worry about maintenance costs or replacing expensive equipment.

Maintenance

Rowing Machine: Owning a rowing machine means you’re responsible for keeping it in working condition. Rowing machines require regular maintenance to ensure smooth operation, like lubricating the chain, cleaning the seat rails, and occasionally replacing parts like the foot straps or handle grips.

Over time, repair costs can add up, especially if the machine is used frequently. Repairs could be expensive if the machine breaks down, leaving you without your primary workout tool.

Gym Memberships: With a gym membership, you don’t have to worry about maintaining equipment. Gym staff care for cleaning, repairs, and replacements, so the machines are always ready. If one rowing machine is out of order, other machines or workout options are typically available. 

Convenience

Rowing Machine: Having a rowing machine at home offers unmatched convenience. You can work out whenever you want without commuting to a gym.

There’s no waiting for machines to become available; you can tailor your workouts to your schedule. However, convenience comes with limitations. If you invest in more home gym gear, you can only use one piece of equipment.

Gym Memberships: While a gym membership requires commuting, it offers the convenience of variety. Whether you want to switch up your cardio routine, try a new class, or get advice from a trainer, everything is available in one location.

Most gyms also offer long hours or 24/7 access, making fitting workouts into a busy schedule easier. Although there may be occasional waits for machines, the wide range of equipment makes it a flexible option.

Space Requirements

Rowing Machine: A rowing machine takes up a significant amount of space, typically around 8-9 feet in length. You’ll need a dedicated area in your home to set up the machine and ensure you have room for the rowing motion. Some rowers can fold up for storage, but they still require space. If you live in a small apartment or home, this could be a major drawback.

Gym Memberships: A gym membership eliminates the need to sacrifice space in your home. Gyms have all the necessary workout equipment, so you don’t have to worry about finding a spot for bulky equipment. You can enjoy a full workout without cluttering your living space, making it an ideal solution for those with limited room at home.

Cardio

Rowing Machine: Rowing is a highly effective cardio workout that engages your entire body. It improves cardiovascular endurance while working the muscles in your legs, core, and arms.

However, it’s just one form of cardio, and doing the same daily workout can become monotonous. If you purchase more equipment, you can only access other popular cardio options like running or cycling.

Gym Memberships: A gym membership gives you access to various cardio machines, including rowing machines, treadmills, stationary bikes, stair climbers, and ellipticals.

This variety lets you switch up your cardio workouts to keep things interesting and prevent burnout. Whether you prefer high-intensity cardio or low-impact workouts, gyms offer options for every preference.

Strength Training

Rowing Machine: While rowing does build muscle strength, particularly in your legs, core, and back, it doesn’t offer the same strength training benefits as weightlifting. A rowing machine is great for toning and endurance but needs more versatile equipment designed specifically for strength, such as free weights or resistance machines.

Gym Memberships: In contrast, gym memberships provide access to a wide range of strength training equipment, including free weights, machines, and resistance bands. Whether you want to focus on specific muscle groups, build strength, or increase muscle mass, a gym offers more comprehensive strength training opportunities. Having trainers can also guide your strength training efforts more effectively.

Weight Loss

Rowing Machine: Rowing is a fantastic calorie burner and can be effective for weight loss with a proper diet. Because it engages the entire body, it helps you burn a significant number of calories in a short amount of time. However, sticking to the same workout routine can reduce effectiveness as your body adapts.

Gym Memberships: A gym membership gives you the flexibility to try various workouts that can aid in weight loss, from high-intensity interval training (HIIT) to cardio classes, as well as access to personal trainers who can customize a weight loss plan. The variety of options helps you stay motivated and avoid workout plateaus, making your weight loss journey more successful in the long term.

Enjoyment

Rowing Machine: If you love rowing and find it enjoyable, having a rowing machine at home can be a great way to stick to your fitness routine. But for many, doing the same workout day after day can become boring, leading to workout fatigue and less motivation over time. Access to other equipment or workout styles is necessary for the excitement of a rowing machine to stay strong.

Gym Memberships: A gym membership offers variety, which is key to keeping workouts fun and engaging. You can try new machines, join group classes, or even participate in gym challenges.

Many people find that a gym’s energy and social atmosphere boost their motivation and make workouts more enjoyable. Plus, the chance to switch up your routine can prevent boredom and keep you returning for more.

Are Rowing Machines For You?

A rowing machine can be essential exercise equipment if you’re focused on full-body cardio workouts and have specific fitness goals that align with rowing’s unique benefits. It might be a solid investment for individuals who enjoy rowing and want the convenience of working out at home.

It offers an effective way to build endurance, improve cardiovascular health, and engage multiple muscle groups. However, buying a rowing machine depends heavily on whether you’re willing to commit to a single form of exercise long-term.

There may be better options for most people than purchasing a rowing machine. They’re expensive, often over $1,000, and take up significant space in your home. 

Over time, they can break down and require maintenance, adding to the overall cost. Additionally, rowing machines can become monotonous and have a different versatility than a gym membership, which provides a relatively inexpensive monthly membership.

Buy a Rowing Machine or Get a Gym Membership?

If you’re debating between buying a rowing machine or signing up for a gym membership, a gym membership might offer more flexibility and long-term benefits.

As mentioned, a gym provides access to various equipment, allowing you to diversify your workouts and target different fitness goals. Most gyms also offer additional services like group classes, personal trainers, and online workout programs to keep you motivated and on track.

The community also helps reduce the risk of injury and keep you accountable, ultimately leading to faster results.

Equipment Variety

A gym membership gives you access to a vast range of exercise equipment beyond just a rowing machine. From treadmills and stair climbers to free weights and resistance machines, you can target different muscle groups and switch up your workouts to avoid boredom. This variety also helps you design a comprehensive fitness plan incorporating cardio, strength training, and flexibility.

Group Classes

Most gyms offer group classes, ranging from high-intensity interval training to yoga and cycling. These classes are a great way to stay motivated, try new workout styles, and challenge yourself. Plus, group classes provide a structured workout led by trained instructors, ensuring you get the most out of each session while keeping things fun and dynamic.

Crunch is both more affordable and more convenient. Try it for free with a Free Trial and experience its variety and value!

New Friendships

Gyms offer a social environment to meet like-minded people with similar fitness goals. Whether striking up a conversation with someone during a class or partnering up for a workout, gyms provide a space to form new friendships. These connections can make exercising more enjoyable and create a sense of community that helps you stay committed to your fitness journey.

Personal Training

Many gyms offer personal training services, giving you access to certified trainers who can tailor workouts to your needs and goals. Personal trainers can help you refine your technique, create personalized fitness plans, and offer guidance to ensure you’re making progress. Working with a trainer can accelerate your results and provide expert advice on avoiding injury.

Access to Online Workouts & Other Perks

In addition to in-person facilities, many gyms offer access to online workouts, virtual classes, and other perks like fitness apps or nutrition coaching.

This adds convenience and flexibility, allowing you to maintain your fitness routine even when you cannot visit the gym. Some gyms also offer members perks like discounts on fitness gear or access to wellness programs.

Less Chance of Injury

With access to professional trainers and a variety of equipment, gyms provide a safer environment to exercise. Trainers can help you learn proper form, reducing the risk of injury, while the availability of different machines allows you to adjust your workout to fit your fitness level. Group classes led by instructors also ensure that exercises are performed correctly.

Accountability & Motivation

A gym membership provides a built-in sense of accountability, whether it’s through group classes, personal trainers, or simply showing up regularly to see progress. The environment, paired with the presence of other motivated gym-goers, can inspire you to push harder and stay committed to your goals. Gyms also often offer fitness challenges or milestones that add a sense of accomplishment.

Faster Results

With access to various workout options, trainers, and structured programs, gyms offer the tools to achieve your fitness goals faster than you might with a single piece of equipment at home. Combining cardio machines, strength training, and group classes creates a balanced workout routine, helping you see results more efficiently and stay on track.

Reach Your Fitness Goals With Crunch

Crunch promotes a culture of positivity, inclusivity, and fun with no judgments by providing an environment for all individuals regardless of their health and fitness goals. Find a Crunch gym near you to try our free trial membership, or join Crunch now. We’re here for you – at the gym or at home. Access the best live & on-demand workouts anytime, anywhere with Crunch+. Ready to get sweaty? Try hundreds of workouts for free! Start your free trial now!